Inside the New Mexico Megachurch Dare That Could Break the IRS Tax Ban

Inside the New Mexico Megachurch Dare That Could Break the IRS Tax Ban

When Legacy Church, a massive evangelical congregation in Albuquerque, New Mexico, openly endorsed Republican candidates from the pulpit and through church communications, it was not a mistake or a rogue pastor losing his composure during a heated sermon. It was a calculated legal trap. By publicly backing conservative contenders in a battleground state, the megachurch deliberately dared the Internal Revenue Service to enforce the Johnson Amendment, a 70-year-old provision of the U.S. tax code that bars tax-exempt houses of worship from endorsing or opposing political candidates.

The move is the latest escalation in a coordinated national campaign to force a Supreme Court showdown over religious speech and tax-exempt status. Rather than hiding behind subtle coded language or issue-based voter guides, religious conservatives are increasingly putting their 501(c)(3) status on the line in plain sight, betting that federal regulators lack the political will—and the constitutional footing—to revoke a church's tax exemption.

The Anatomy of a Calculated Provocation

For decades, the unspoken truce between American churches and the federal government rested on a simple trade. Houses of worship received automatic tax-exempt status, allowing them to collect billions of dollars in tax-deductible donations without paying corporate income or property taxes, and in exchange, they agreed to stay out of partisan candidate endorsements.

Legacy Church, led by Pastor Steve Smothermon, has spent years pushing right up against that boundary, hosting high-profile conservative figures and framing political battles in stark spiritual terms. By crossing the line into explicit candidate endorsements in New Mexico—a state where evangelical voters hold significant sway in congressional and local races—the church shifted from subtle political alignment to direct institutional campaigning.

This is not happening in a vacuum. Legal advocacy groups like Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) have spent more than a decade organizing "Pulpit Freedom Sunday" initiatives, explicitly recruiting pastors to record their political endorsements and mail them directly to the IRS. The goal has never been to survive an audit quietly. The goal is to get punished.

To challenge a law in federal court, a plaintiff must prove legal standing—meaning they have suffered a concrete, measurable injury caused by the government. For years, conservative legal strategists have hit a wall because the IRS has largely refused to take the bait. Without an actual revocation of tax-exempt status or a punitive tax assessment, churches cannot easily drag the Johnson Amendment before the conservative supermajority on the U.S. Supreme Court.

Why the IRS Rarely Pulls the Trigger

If the law is clear on paper, why does a New Mexico megachurch feel comfortable flouting it in broad daylight? The answer lies in a mixture of bureaucratic paralysis, political scar tissue, and statutory roadblocks.

Enforcing tax law against a religious institution is an administrative nightmare for the IRS. Under the Church Audit Procedures Act, the agency cannot simply open an investigation into a congregation based on a news report or a watchdog complaint. A high-ranking Treasury official must first sign off on a formal "reasonable belief" determination that the church may no longer qualify for tax exemption.

Even when the agency clears that hurdle, the political fallout is severe. Following the 2013 Tea Party targeting controversy, in which the IRS faced bipartisan fury over heightened scrutiny of conservative nonprofit groups, enforcement against politically active tax-exempt organizations plummeted. Career bureaucrats learned a hard lesson: policing political speech near election cycles invites immediate congressional subpoenas, budget cuts, and accusations of partisan weaponization.

Consider a hypothetical scenario to see how this plays out in practice. Suppose an IRS field agent flags a recorded sermon from a 10,000-member congregation endorsing a Senate candidate. Before a single subpoena is issued, the file must pass through multiple layers of executive review, survive potential litigation over First Amendment boundaries, and weather a predictable media firestorm framing the federal government as attacking religious liberty. Faced with dwindling enforcement budgets and massive backlogs of complex corporate tax audits, the agency routinely chooses to look the other way.

Only once in modern history has the IRS successfully revoked a church's tax-exempt status over partisan campaigning. That happened in 1995, when the Church at Pierce Creek in Binghamton, New York, took out full-page newspaper ads in USA Today and The Washington Times urging Christians not to vote for Bill Clinton. The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the revocation in 2000, ruling that the church remained free to speak on political issues—it simply could not subsidize partisan campaigning with tax-deductible dollars.

The Money Behind the Pulpit

The public debate over the Johnson Amendment is almost always framed around free speech and the First Amendment. Yet veterans of campaign finance law know the real stakes are financial.

A 501(c)(3) religious organization enjoys privileges that traditional political action committees and even dark-money 501(c)(4) social welfare groups can only dream of. Every dollar donated to a church is tax-deductible for the donor. Furthermore, unlike other nonprofits, churches are exempt from filing Form 990, the annual financial disclosure document that forces charities to reveal their top donors, executive compensation, and major expenditures to the public.

If the Johnson Amendment is struck down or rendered unenforceable, houses of worship instantly become the ultimate black-box political vehicles.

  • Unlimited Tax-Deductible Political Giving: Wealthy donors could write massive checks to a church, claim a personal income tax deduction, and watch those funds flow directly into voter mobilization, campaign literature, and candidate endorsements.
  • Zero Donor Disclosure: Because churches do not file Form 990, neither the Federal Election Commission nor the public would ever know who funded a church's multi-million-dollar political operation.
  • Built-In Distribution Networks: Megachurches already possess sophisticated media production teams, massive email lists, SMS blast infrastructure, and weekly captive audiences that rival regional political party apparatuses.

Watchdog groups like Americans United for Separation of Church and State and the Freedom From Religion Foundation have repeatedly filed complaints with the IRS over explicit endorsements by megachurches in New Mexico, Texas, and Florida. Their argument is straightforward: taxpayers should not be forced to subsidize partisan political campaigns through the tax code, regardless of whether the check is written to a secular charity or a house of worship.

The Counter-Argument From the Pew

To dismiss the megachurch pushback as mere partisan opportunism misses a genuine constitutional tension that has troubled legal scholars across the ideological spectrum.

Lyndon B. Johnson introduced the amendment in 1954 not out of a grand philosophical commitment to the separation of church and state, but as a political maneuver to silence two conservative tax-exempt foundations in Texas that were funding his primary opponent. Because the restriction was tacked onto the tax code without extensive floor debate, critics argue it created an arbitrary speech restriction that forces pastors to censor themselves on matters of moral and civic consequence.

Defenders of religious autonomy contend that the government should not condition tax-exempt status on the surrender of core constitutional rights—a legal doctrine known as unconstitutional conditions. From the perspective of pastors like Smothermon, faith does not stop at the edge of the ballot box. When candidates take opposing stances on abortion, religious schools, or marriage, church leaders argue that naming which candidate aligns with their theology is an exercise of religious duty, not a corporate campaign contribution.

There is also a persistent double standard in how the law is applied on the ground. Historically, Black churches have served as vital organizing hubs for civil rights and voter mobilization, frequently hosting Democratic candidates in the weeks leading up to an election. While most of those appearances technically stop short of an explicit "vote for this person" endorsement—relying instead on warm introductions and shared pulpit time—critics on the right argue that the IRS has long tolerated partisan signaling on the left while threatening conservative congregations with audits.

A Legal Landscape Tilting Toward the Churches

The timing of Legacy Church's defiance is no accident. The legal ground beneath the Johnson Amendment has shifted dramatically over the past decade, largely due to a string of Supreme Court rulings expanding religious liberty protections.

In cases like Trinity Lutheran, Espinoza, and Carson v. Makin, the Supreme Court repeatedly ruled that the government cannot exclude religious institutions from public benefits simply because of their religious character. Meanwhile, in Citizens United v. FEC, the Court dismantled long-standing restrictions on corporate political speech, ruling that the First Amendment prohibits the government from restricting independent political expenditures by nonprofit corporations.

Legal scholars who track church-state litigation point out that if a church finally forces the IRS to revoke its tax-exempt status, the resulting lawsuit would hit a federal judiciary deeply skeptical of regulatory limits on religious expression. Even without a Supreme Court ruling, executive branch policies have already weakened the law. A 2017 executive order directed the Treasury Department not to take adverse action against religious organizations for speaking about moral or political issues from a religious perspective, effectively instructing the IRS to stand down unless a church engages in extreme, undeniable campaign intervention.

That leaves the Johnson Amendment in a state of legal limbo. It remains on the books, intimidating smaller congregations that cannot afford a prolonged legal battle with the Department of Justice, while large, well-funded megachurches treat it as a paper tiger.

What Happens When the Guardrails Disappear

The standoff in New Mexico is less about a single election cycle and more about the permanent transformation of American political infrastructure. When a megachurch endorses candidates without consequence, it sends an unmistakable signal to thousands of other congregations across the country: the cop has left the beat.

If the federal government refuses to enforce the ban, or if the courts eventually strike it down, the boundary between Sunday service and campaign headquarters will vanish overnight. Political operatives will inevitably court pastors not just for their moral influence, but for their tax-exempt bank accounts and opaque donor rolls. Candidates will face immense pressure to pass religious litmus tests to secure institutional backing, while congregants who hold minority political views within their own churches will find their tithes funding campaigns they actively oppose.

Legacy Church placed a deliberate bet that Washington lacks the nerve to enforce its own tax laws against a powerful religious institution, and until the IRS proves otherwise, every pulpit in America is effectively open for political business.

EM

Emily Martin

An enthusiastic storyteller, Emily Martin captures the human element behind every headline, giving voice to perspectives often overlooked by mainstream media.