Why the New York Times Got the Best TV Shows of the Century Right and Wrong

Why the New York Times Got the Best TV Shows of the Century Right and Wrong

Ranking art is a fool's errand. We do it anyway because arguments keep us warm. When The New York Times released its massive ranking of the best TV shows of the 21st century after surveying more than five hundred actors, writers, producers, and showrunners, the resulting list acted as a giant mirror. It wasn't just a tally of good television. It was a self-portrait of an industry voting on its own reflection.

At the summit sat Breaking Bad, Walter White's slow-motion moral explosion taking the crown ahead of heavyweight competitors like The Wire, Mad Men, and Succession. Some choices felt inevitable. Others felt like safe consensus picks designed to offend the fewest voters in a massive professional pool. If you look past the shiny top ten, you find an ongoing identity crisis about what television actually is, how it functions, and why certain stories capture our collective obsession while others fade into streaming oblivion.

When Five Hundred Industry Insiders Vote on Greatness

You have to understand who built this list to understand why it looks the way it does. The voters weren't casual viewers binge-watching on weekends with a phone in hand. They were people working inside television production. Writers rooms, sound stages, editing bays, and executive suites. When insiders vote, they reward craftsmanship that survives the grueling mechanics of making television. They vote for structure, airtight plotting, disciplined writing, and undeniable execution.

That explains why Breaking Bad won the top spot. Think about the mechanics of Vince Gilligan's masterpiece. Every single season maintained a narrative tension that most shows struggle to sustain for three episodes. Walter White starts as an underpaid high school chemistry teacher washing cars on the side to make ends meet. He gets a cancer diagnosis. He steps into a dirty mobile home with a former student named Jesse Pinkman.

From there, the engine never stops turning. It's a masterclass in escalation. Walter doesn't stumble into crime by accident; he stays because he discovers he is exceptionally good at being ruthless. By the time he delivers his final confession—admitting he didn't do it for his family, but for himself because it made him feel alive—the show has executed a complete moral inversion. Industry professionals respect that kind of structural discipline. There is no bloat. There are no wheel-spinning bottle episodes that go nowhere. It is tight, propulsive, and airtight. You can argue about whether it's your favorite show, but finding a structural flaw in its five-season run is nearly impossible.

Why The Wire Came Second and Why That Matters

Coming in right behind it was David Simon's The Wire. If Breaking Bad is a high-octane thriller about individual corruption, The Wire is a cold, sociological autopsy of an entire American city. Set in Baltimore, it moves methodically from the street-level drug trade to the docks, the school system, city hall, and the newsroom.

It doesn't care about making you comfortable. It doesn't give you tidy emotional payoffs. Characters you love are chewed up and spat out by institutional indifference. Police officers, politicians, dealers, and addicts are all cogs in machinery that refuses to care about human collateral.

Placing The Wire at number two feels correct, but it also reveals the limits of industry voting. The Wire was famously ignored by major awards during its original broadcast run. It was too slow, too dense, and too bleak for mainstream audiences who wanted easy heroes. By the time voters caught up to its genius, history had already crowned it. Yet, putting it behind Breaking Bad shows a predictable preference for stories driven by charismatic protagonists with clear arcs. The Wire refuses the protagonist model entirely. The true main character is the city itself. When you ask five hundred people to vote, the individual hero almost always wins over the systemic tragedy.

The Strange Omission of the Godfather of Prestige TV

Every major list comes with a glaring omission that sparks immediate outrage online. This one had a massive elephant in the room that wasn't even eligible: The Sopranos.

Because the criteria demanded that shows must have premiered on or after January 1, 2000, David Chase's mob masterpiece missed the cutoff by a matter of months, having debuted in January 1999. That technicality feels absurd. Modern television as we know it—the era of morally compromised antiheroes, cinematic budgets, complex serialized storytelling, and deep psychological exploration—does not exist without Tony Soprano walking into a New Jersey psychiatrist's office.

Leaving off the show that invented the prestige format creates a weird historical distortion. It is like ranking the greatest rock albums of the 1970s while disqualifying Led Zeppelin because they formed in late 1968. Without The Sopranos paving the road, Breaking Bad, Mad Men, and Succession would never have been greenlit. Any assessment of twenty-first-century television that has to invent bureaucratic rules to exclude its foundational text carries an inherent flaw.

Comedy Dominates the Middle Tier

One of the most fascinating takeaways from the broader rankings is how heavily industry professionals leaned into comedy. Look at the upper and middle tiers: Fleabag, Veep, 30 Rock, Curb Your Enthusiasm, Atlanta, The Office, Arrested Development.

We used to treat comedy as second-class television. Half-hour sitcoms were filler between dramatic tentpoles. This century completely inverted that hierarchy. Shows like Veep and 30 Rock weaponized dialogue with a density that rivaled any prestige drama. They packed more jokes, social critique, and verbal gymnastics into twenty-two minutes than most movies manage in two hours.

Take Atlanta. Donald Glover's creation defied genre altogether. It was billed as a comedy, but it operated as a surrealist mood piece, a horror vignette, a social satire, and an artistic experiment. It proved that half-hour television could take risks that billion-dollar movie studios wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole. Voters recognized that the sharpest writing of our time often wore a mask of humor to smuggle in harsh truths about modern life.

The Globalization Mirage in Modern Television

If the top ten tells us what American professionals value, it also exposes a glaring blind spot regarding international television. Out of the top ten shows on the list, nine are American, and one (Fleabag) is British.

Even when foreign-language sensations like Squid Game or historical epics like Shogun make an appearance further down the roster, they usually arrive with heavy backing from American streaming giants or Hollywood production pipelines. Truly native, non-English international television struggles to break into the insulated bubble of American critical consensus.

We live in a global streaming era where a viewer in Tokyo or São Paulo can watch the exact same show on the exact same day as someone in Chicago. Yet, our critical institutions remain stubbornly domestic in their tastes. The stories we celebrate as defining our era are still overwhelmingly filtered through an Anglo-American lens. Until critics and industry voters expand their horizons past the boundaries of English-language production, these lists will remain provincial snapshots rather than global maps.

What We Talk About When We Talk About Peak Television

Lists like this force us to confront what we actually want from our entertainment. Do we want comfort, or do we want disruption? Do we want characters who heal, or do we want characters who rot from the inside out?

The dominant television of the past twenty-five years chose rot. From Walter White to Don Draper, from Tony Soprano to Kendall Roy, our greatest television creations were studies in moral decay. We spent two decades watching deeply flawed, often monstrous individuals navigate power structures that rewarded their worst impulses.

Perhaps that is why these shows resonated so deeply. They matched the messy, fractured reality of the century itself. Cinema retreated into safe, predictable intellectual property, relying on comic book universes and nostalgic reboots to guarantee box office returns. Television picked up the slack. It took risks, it embraced ambiguity, and it trusted audiences to handle complex, unresolved narratives.

The New York Times list is imperfect. It relies on institutional biases, enforces arbitrary cutoff dates, and leans heavily into safe American consensus. But it captures a golden age where the small screen became the only place willing to look human nature straight in the eye without blinking.

EM

Emily Martin

An enthusiastic storyteller, Emily Martin captures the human element behind every headline, giving voice to perspectives often overlooked by mainstream media.