Stop Watching President Herzog Because He Has Zero Real Power Over Israel’s Next Government

Stop Watching President Herzog Because He Has Zero Real Power Over Israel’s Next Government

Every major newsroom from New Delhi to New York is staring at the wrong door in Jerusalem.

When both Benjamin Netanyahu and Gadi Eisenkot come up short of a 61-seat Knesset majority, the lazy consensus kicks into overdrive. Pundits immediately pivot to the President’s Residence. They frame Isaac Herzog as the ultimate kingmaker, the wise referee holding the whistle over a deadlocked democracy.

That narrative is pure political theater.

If you are watching Herzog to see who forms Israel’s next government, you are misunderstanding the Basic Law of Israel from the ground up. The presidency in Israel is not an executive office. It is a ceremonial mirror. Herzog does not pick the winner; he merely reads the math that party leaders hand him in closed-door consultations. Focusing on the President when a coalition stalls is like staring at the scoreboard operator instead of the players on the pitch.

The Illusion of the Presidential Kingmaker

Foreign correspondents love a clean, single-character drama. It is much easier to write a headline about one man holding the fate of a nation than it is to explain the brutal, multi-variable calculus of Israeli coalition horse-trading.

Under Section 7 of Basic Law: The Government, the President’s role after an election is strictly procedural. He meets with representatives of every faction elected to the Knesset. He asks one simple question: Who do you recommend to form the government?

Then, he adds up the numbers.

If 61 Members of Knesset (MKs) recommend a candidate, the President has zero discretion. He must hand the mandate to that person. Even when nobody hits 61—the exact deadlock scenario pitting Netanyahu’s bloc against Eisenkot’s camp—Herzog is not free to follow his personal instincts or play ideological matchmaker. He is legally and politically bound to assign the mandate to the candidate with the highest mathematical probability of assembling a functioning coalition.

I have watched political analysts burn entire news cycles predicting which way a president will "lean" during a deadlock. They dissect body language. They analyze old speeches. They treat a constitutional rubber stamp like a Supreme Court swing vote. Every single time, the actual decision comes down to cold arithmetic in Knesset backrooms hours before the cameras even roll at Beit HaNassi.

Why the Netanyahu vs. Eisenkot Binary Is a Trap

The second failure of mainstream coverage is framing this stalemate as a two-man duel between Benjamin Netanyahu and Gadi Eisenkot.

Yes, Netanyahu commands the gravitational center of the Israeli right, and Eisenkot—the former IDF Chief of Staff turned political heavyweight—represents the pragmatic, security-first alternative trying to unify the opposition. Framing them as the sole protagonists misses how power actually operates in a 120-seat proportional representation system.

In Israel, the two largest blocs rarely decide the outcome. The kingmakers are the 6-to-10-seat hinge parties sitting on the ideological margins.

  • The Haredi (Ultra-Orthodox) factions: Shas and United Torah Judaism do not care about abstract constitutional theories. They care about yeshiva funding, military draft exemptions, and control over religious institutions.
  • The ideological right and secular nationalists: Parties like Yisrael Beiteinu or smaller religious Zionist splinters demand specific ministerial portfolios—Finance, Defense, or Interior—that carry massive budgetary control.
  • The Arab parties: Ra'am and Hadash-Ta'al hold seats that can block a right-wing majority simply by existing, yet ideological red lines keep them out of most governing math.

Neither Netanyahu nor Eisenkot owns the board. Both men are effectively hostages to smaller faction leaders who know that withholding seven seats collapses the entire mathematical equation. Herzog cannot force a small party to swallow a coalition partner it hates. Only budget allocations, ministry splits, and legislative vetoes can do that.

Dismantling the Wrong Questions

When an Israeli election ends in a hung parliament, search engines flood with the exact same predictable queries. Almost all of them are built on false premises.

Can President Herzog force a unity government?

No. He can beg for one. He can give an emotional televised address about national cohesion and external threats. He can lock Netanyahu and Eisenkot in a room with coffee and pastries for six hours. He cannot compel a single MK to vote confidence in a government. In 2019 and 2020, Reuven Rivlin tried every rhetorical and procedural trick in the book to force a unity deal between Netanyahu and Benny Gantz. It failed twice, sending the country straight into repeat elections before a global pandemic finally forced their hands.

Does the party with the most votes automatically get the first mandate?

Wrong again. Unlike first-past-the-post systems in the United Kingdom or the United States, winning a plurality of the popular vote in Israel guarantees nothing. Tzipi Livni’s Kadima party won the most seats in 2009 (28 seats to Likud’s 27), yet Netanyahu got the mandate and became Prime Minister because he controlled a larger bloc of recommending parties. Raw vote totals are vanity metrics; coalition bloc totals are the only currency that clears.

What happens if both candidates fail to reach 61 seats?

The system enters a rigid statutory countdown. The first candidate gets 28 days, with a possible 14-day extension at the President’s discretion. If they fail, the President can hand the mandate to a second candidate for 28 days. If that second attempt implodes, the mandate shifts entirely away from the President and drops onto the Knesset floor. At that point, any 61 MKs can sign a petition within 21 days naming anyone in parliament to form a government. If nobody gets 61 signatures, the Knesset automatically dissolves and Israel heads back to the ballot box.

The Real Power Mechanics Nobody Wants to Explain

To understand what actually breaks a Netanyahu–Eisenkot deadlock, stop reading diplomatic cables and start studying coalition agreements.

In his seminal work on parliamentary democracies, political scientist Arend Lijphart demonstrated how proportional systems trade decisive single-party rule for consensus-building—until polarization breaks the consensus mechanism entirely. Israel has crossed that threshold. Because ideological camps view each other as existential threats rather than mere policy rivals, standard compromise fails.

When standard compromise fails, three shadow mechanisms take over:

  1. The Norwegian Law Expansion: By allowing ministers to resign their Knesset seats so the next candidate on their party list can enter parliament, leaders artificially manufacture extra patronage jobs. More jobs mean more loyalists who have zero incentive to trigger a new election that would cost them their salaries.
  2. Defector Poaching: When a bloc sits at 59 or 60 seats, party leaders stop negotiating with whole factions and start targeting vulnerable individual MKs. Offering a backbencher a deputy minister title or a safe spot on a future party slate is often cheaper than conceding a major policy demand to a rival party leader.
  3. Constructive Vote of No Confidence Threats: Even if a narrow government scrapes together 61 votes, it governs under a permanent sword of Damocles. Every single member of a 61-seat coalition holds an effective veto over legislation.

The Downside of Ignoring the Presidency Completely

Dismissing Herzog’s formal power does not mean his office is 100% irrelevant. There is a massive caveat to this contrarian view, and ignoring it will blindside you when the 28-day clock starts ticking.

While Herzog cannot create a majority, he controls sequencing and legitimacy.

Deciding who goes first matters enormously in psychological warfare. If Herzog gives Netanyahu the first 28-day window, Netanyahu gains the momentum of inevitability. He gets to sit at the head of the table, distribute ministerial drafts, and pressure hesitant fence-sitters into joining before the train leaves the station. Conversely, handing the first shot to Eisenkot signals to the political class that the Netanyahu era has hit a hard mathematical wall, instantly encouraging opportunistic defectors on the right to start hedging their bets.

Furthermore, Herzog holds the 14-day extension trigger. If a candidate reaches day 28 with 59 seats and claims they are inches away from a breakthrough, Herzog can either grant the two extra weeks to close the deal or pull the plug and hand the baton to the rival. That single scheduling decision can make or break a fragile negotiation.

How to Actually Track an Israeli Coalition Deadlock

If you want to know who will actually sit in the Prime Minister’s Office before the official press release drops, stop watching the cameras outside the President's Residence. Watch three concrete indicators instead:

  • Track Knesset Finance Committee assignments: Before a formal coalition is ever announced, temporary parliamentary committees are formed. Whoever controls the Arrangements Committee and the Finance Committee already has a functional 61-seat operating agreement in place.
  • Watch the silent faction leaders: When an Israeli politician is about to flip blocs or cut a backroom deal, they stop doing television interviews. Sudden radio silence from a mid-sized party leader is the loudest signal in Jerusalem.
  • Follow the legal and draft-law exemptions: Look at the exact wording of proposed amendments to Basic Laws. Coalition deals in Israel are rarely built on trust; they are built on pre-passed legislative poison pills designed to prevent partners from betraying each other six months later.

Isaac Herzog will shake hands, deliver solemn remarks about unity, and sign the official mandate letter when the dust settles. He will look like the man steering the ship. Do not fall for the optics. The real steering is happening in windowless Knesset offices over cold coffee and legislative spreadsheets, and the outcome will be decided long before the President ever picks up his pen.

EM

Emily Martin

An enthusiastic storyteller, Emily Martin captures the human element behind every headline, giving voice to perspectives often overlooked by mainstream media.